Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
The store says you should have seen the hazard. A New Mexico owner must use ordinary care even when a danger is obvious, and a visitor found 20% at fault is still awarded 80% of the damages.

You reached for a case of water on a top shelf, and the stack above it came down on your shoulder. Now there are X-rays, a sling, and a store manager who says accidents happen. In New Mexico, a property owner who fails to use ordinary care to keep the premises safe can be responsible for your injuries, even when the danger was in plain sight. What the owner knew, who controlled the hazard, and which deadline applies all matter. A New Mexico premises liability attorney can sort out all three.

New Mexico Owes Nearly Every Lawful Visitor the Same Duty

Older premises law sorted injured visitors into categories, such as invitees and licensees, and gave each group a different level of protection. New Mexico dropped that system in 1994. The New Mexico Supreme Court held that an owner or occupier must use ordinary care, meaning the care a reasonably careful person would use, to keep the property reasonably safe for everyone who enters with permission, whether that permission was stated or implied.

That rule covers a shopper, a festival ticket holder, a rental guest, and a friend at a barbecue. Trespassers remain a separate group with more limited protection. A separate state law also treats a person allowed to hunt, fish, camp, hike, or use land for similar outdoor recreation free of charge like a trespasser. For other lawful visitors, the question is whether the owner or occupier acted reasonably under all the circumstances, including how likely an injury was, how serious it could be, and how hard it would have been to avoid the risk.

What the Owner Knew, or Should Have Found

Whether an owner is responsible for a fall depends in part on what the owner knew, should have found, or caused. The New Mexico Supreme Court has approved a jury instruction that treats an owner as knowing about any condition a reasonable inspection would have revealed, and about any condition the owner or its employees created.

Here is how the second part works in a store. When an employee leaves a pallet in the aisle, the store created the hazard, and it cannot claim it never knew. The same reasoning applies to merchandise an employee stacked too high.

The owner also cannot escape responsibility by pointing out that the hazard was easy to see. New Mexico abolished the old rule that an owner owes nothing for dangers in plain sight. The court held that some carelessness by visitors is foreseeable and that owners have to account for it. A shopper carrying bags or watching a child is an everyday example. A visitor’s inattention can reduce the award, and the owner’s duty stays in place.

Where These Injuries Happen

Premises claims in New Mexico arise in ordinary places, including these:

  • Retail stores, where falling merchandise, spills, and cluttered aisles injure shoppers
  • Festivals, fairs, and concerts, where cables, uneven ground, temporary stairs, and crowd control are the job of whoever runs the grounds
  • Short-term rentals, where a guest enters with the owner’s permission and the host must keep the areas and fixtures it controls reasonably safe
  • Parking lots, where potholes, poor lighting, and confusing traffic flow put pedestrians in the path of cars
  • Apartment complexes, bars, hotels, and garages that skimp on lighting, locks, or guards

Responsibility depends on who controlled the hazard. The New Mexico Supreme Court has tied a contractor’s responsibility to the equipment and areas it actually controlled, and a landlord’s responsibility to the areas under its control. The right defendant might be the owner, a tenant, an event promoter, or a property manager. Guests hurt at vacation homes can read more about Airbnb and short-term rental injuries.

When a Crime Happens on the Property

A business open to the public must use ordinary care to protect customers from harm by other people that it could reasonably foresee, even when that harm is a crime. The New Mexico Supreme Court applied that duty to a bar with a history of shootings, stabbings, and assaults. The bar had one bouncer who usually arrived at 9 p.m., and an employee watched an argument for almost five minutes without stopping it or calling police.

In these cases, the jury compares the owner’s failure with the attacker’s conduct and assigns each a share of the fault. The owner pays its share. As the danger grows, so does the care the owner must use. Our post on injuries from inadequate security lists common safety measures, such as cameras, lighting, locks, and security staff.

Claims Against a City, County, or the State

Public bodies in New Mexico are immune from most injury lawsuits. The Tort Claims Act, the law that sets when a public body can be sued, removes that protection when public employees are negligent in operating or maintaining any building, public park, machinery, equipment, or furnishings. A fall at a county office, a city recreation center, or a state park can fit.

The deadlines are much shorter. The law requires written notice to the correct official within 90 days after the incident (not counting up to 90 days when your injury leaves you unable to give notice), unless the agency already had actual notice that a claim was likely. The right official is the state’s Risk Management Division for claims against the state, the mayor for a city, the county clerk for a county, the superintendent for a school district, or the head of any other public body. The notice must state the time, place, and circumstances of the injury. 

The lawsuit itself must be filed within two years. The statute gives a child injured before age seven until their ninth birthday. New Mexico courts also generally will not let the notice or filing deadline bar the claim of a child too young to meet it, even when a parent could have acted.

For a claim against a private owner or business, the deadline to file a lawsuit is three years from the date of the injury. An injured child generally has at least until one year after turning 18. For claims against a city, county, school district, or the state, the Tort Claims Act’s notice and filing rules apply instead, subject to the exceptions described above.

Evidence That Shows What the Owner Knew

Proof of a hazard disappears quickly. Spills get mopped, broken steps get repaired, and surveillance systems can record over old footage. Take these steps as soon as your health allows:

  • Report the injury to a manager and ask for a copy of the incident report, or at least the report number
  • Ask the business, in writing, to save any surveillance video of the area
  • Photograph the hazard, the lighting, and any warning signs, or the lack of them
  • Get the names and phone numbers of witnesses and employees who saw the scene
  • Keep the shoes and clothing you wore
  • Get medical care right away and keep every follow-up appointment

Head injuries deserve special attention. Some concussion symptoms can take hours or days to appear, and the CDC advises that an older adult who falls and hits their head should see a doctor right away. Medical records made the day of the incident tie your injuries to the fall.

How Shared Fault Affect Your Claim

Premises cases follow the same fault rules as other personal injury claims in New Mexico. The state uses pure comparative negligence, which means your share of the blame lowers your award but never bars it. If a jury finds you 20% at fault for not watching your step, your award drops by 20%, and the jury still awards you the rest. When several parties share blame, such as a parking lot owner and the driver who hit you, each one usually pays only the share of fault assigned to it.

Talk With a New Mexico Premises Liability Lawyer

Evidence fades and deadlines run from the day you are hurt. Hunt Law Firm prepares every case as if it is going to trial, offers free consultations, and charges no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you. Contact Hunt Law today to schedule your free case evaluation.